5. 4. And furthermor. We have a whole article related to why they haven't used eagles to fly the One Ring to Mount Doom. From the first revelation of the fiery letters in his home at Bag End, Frodo has known that he cannot and must not wield the Ring. 2. Doom would shoot arrows at the eagles as they land.". You ask Gandalf why they can't just ride the eagles to Mordor. Saruman. "Orcs stationed at Mt. Twice he tries to give it away, first to Gandalf and again to Galadriel. "Orcs stationed along the border of Mordor would shoot arrows at the eagles.". Notes: GRAB SOME SNACKS! While I don't disagree with anything @randalthor wrote, there is a much more important issue preventing Gandalf the While from just walking to Mount Doom and destroying it, and it's the same one that prevented Gandalf the Grey from doing so. At least, I've always assumed they'd rule Middle-earth with an iron talon. [wp] You are Frodo and the council of Elrond has just finished. The One Ring, like Sauron, is a bad influence on people. Doom would shoot arrows at the eagles as they land.". "Sauron would send the flying Nazgûl after the eagles.". 3. You've accepted your mission to destroy the ring. Gandalf has a huge desire to help the world and do good, and holds extreme power. He was a White Wizard and the leader of the Order of the five mightiest wizards, sent to Middle-earth to help fight the evil emerging in the East. 3. The final and greatest temptation in the novel is that of Frodo at the Cracks of Doom. Always he has known that it must be destroyed. And that is why Gandalf can't touch it. 4. Answer (1 of 13): There're a few ways to look at this question: 1 Orthodox 'canon'. Like the other user said, it would corrupt him. Frodo wouldn' have to walk to the Mount Doom. This chapter came out to 9.5k, but I almost made it longer XD I guess I should add the slow burn tag at some point. The ring would manipulate that and convince him he's doing good, and he'd probably become as bad as Saruman. "Orcs stationed at Mt. Here's an excellent rundown of in-universe explanations, and a few real-world ones. Twice he tries to give it away, first to Gandalf and again to Galadriel. Gandalf could touch the Ring and take it to Mount Doom. It summarizes frequent Usenet discussions in rec.arts.books.tolkien of the so-called "Eagle plan" whereby the Eagles are used to fly the ring to Mount Doom. (See the end of the chapter for more notes.) He is . Summary: one ring to rule them all one ring to bind them one ring to bring them all and in the darkness gun. It is risky for eagles to fly the ring to Mount Doom, Sauron would notice them immediately. However, he eventually succumbed to the One Ring's power and became a villain. A LotR Au where everything is the same, but Pippin and Merry have guns. From the first revelation of the fiery letters in his home at Bag End, Frodo has known that he cannot and must not wield the Ring. 4. Always he has known that it must be destroyed. OR. What was intended as an uplifting end to the Fellowship's journey has instead prompted many fans to question why Gandalf didn't simply ask the eagles to take the Ring-bearing Frodo directly from his hole in Bag End to the infamous Mount Doom, where he could toss the item into the flames without Gollum 's interference or an extended period of . 6. 4y. Gandalf states exactly in the text of the Lord of the Rings why he can't take the ring. Because he can not resist the will to 'do good' with the coercive force/domination power the ring represents. 5. It is risky for eagles to fly the ring to Mount Doom, Sauron would notice them immediately. However, Gandalf couldn't take an Eagle because he didn't control them. The final and greatest temptation in the novel is that of Frodo at the Cracks of Doom. 6. The Eagles were controlled by Radagasts'. Though someone could start out with good intentions, the Ring would eventually corrupt them. 2. Saruman was once one of the most powerful wizards in the world. "Orcs stationed along the border of Mordor would shoot arrows at the eagles.". "Sauron would send the flying Nazgûl after the eagles.". An Archive of Our Own, a project of the Organization for Transformative Works To expand on that some, the ring enhances its wearer's desires and will. In short, the eagles would also be tempted to take the ring.
Hollow Knight Speedrun World Record, Barbour International Puffer Jacket, Range Rover L405 Facelift, Dior Poison Girl Dupe, Uk Vaccine Mandate Protest, 3 Reasons Why School Should Not Start Later,
