Why didn't isildur destroy the Ring when he could? When push comes to shove nothing Sauron does matters(and certainly nothing the Nazgul do) in the SA other than winning the trust of Ar . Elrond has class and is not going to push his buddy into the pits of Mt Doom. Surely, by the time of the War of the Ring, Elrond understood that Isildur had no choice in the matter. Elrond doesn't take Isildur to Mount Doom to destroy it and does not press him to, other than council him, because in truth he does not know that it is the embodiment of Sauron's power. He alone stood by his father in that last mortal contest; and by Gil-galad only Círdan stood, and I. You shall not have it." I see my eldest son approach, he looks with great sadness upon the body of his grandfather. ELROND Isildur! Along with three of his four sons. Elrond didn't actually know much about the One Ring at this point, as did anyone else (that was still alive, at least. Elendil was the High King of the Númenóreans in realms in exile of Gondor and Arnor. Even once the initial movies ended, the world of Middle-earth has remained through the Shadow of Mordor video games and the Hobbit trilogy. Isildur kept the ring in secret, and I think that secrecy is the main reason Elrond didn't push his case. He heard footsteps approaching him, and looked up to meet Elrond's eyes. That is tidings indeed.'Alas! "Long ago Isildur made a vow to bind his . Among other properties the Ring had incredibly strong mind-control powers when matters came down to its self-preservation. Apr 19 Isildur, Gildor, and Elrond leave Barad-dûr Apr 24 Gildor and Elrond part from Isildur at Morannon Apr 25 Gildor and Elrond camp at Emyn Muil Apr 27 Gildor and Elrond cross Anduin at Celebrant Apr 28 Isildur arrives at Rauros and crosses Anduin; Gildor and Elrond arrive in Lothlórien He it was who cut the One Ring from Sauron's hand with his slain father's broken sword. Isildur keeps the Ring because everyone but the Elves are drawn to it - Saruman is (he is not a servant of Sauron as the movies show, he wants the Ring for . The Lord of the Rings books and movies have become a staple of pop culture throughout the years. Elrond would make an excellent anchor point for the whole story line. Elrond never leads to Samanth Naur, Isildur isn't even the one to defeat Sauron. Elrond did not know how dangerous the Ring was at the time. The Lord of the Rings films display worlds full of magic, fantasy, and wonder, but they also feature a lot of battles. If Cirdan or Elrond smote Isildur then and there they likely would also be corrupted by the ring not to mention the fact that the armies of men would likely learn of the killing of their new king. Isildur insisted on keeping the ring for the memory of his father and brother. If Cirdan or Elrond smote Isildur then and there they likely would also be corrupted by the ring not to mention the fact that the armies of men would likely learn of the killing of their new king. … He couldn't have known that Isildur would die so soon, and that the ring would go missing. ELROND Throw it in the fire! The ring would have been destroyed, as it was at the end of the War of the Ring. For in destroying the ring through such an act of treachery and betrayal, Elrond would have destroyed himself - and likely broken the Last Alliance into a brutal war between Elves and betrayed Men. Cut to scene of Elrond and Isildur in the Crack of Doom. Elrond is played through Hugo Weaving. 5 Characters We'd Like To See In Amazon's Lord Of The Rings Series "No, Isildur, you must listen, the Ring must be destroyed now," Círdan states. 2. Isildur (with an evil look on his face): No. But only by a little bit, especially when compared to Men at their peak. Warning: Non-consensual sex. 7y. "The Ring is mine. Isildur is transfixed by the Ring, and he probably wouldn't even notice if Elrond made a move of any sort. Answer (1 of 4): From descending to ascending order of importance: 1. Possession Pairing: Elrond/Isildur; Elrond/Gil-galad mentioned Rating: NC-17 Summary: Isildur is in possession of the One Ring, but that's not all he wants. There, Elrond spoke to the new King of Gondor and entreated of him to cast it in to the fires, for from whence it came, thus can it be destroyed. Elrond and Isildur, each in command of their own forces but never more than a shout from each other, watched the unfolding tableau in horror, as did Cirdan, who ever remained close to Elrond's side. What happened to Bard, Beorn and Radagast after the remaining Hobbit movie? Elrond pushing Isildur off the cliff as a spur of the moment response to Isildur not destroying the Ring would be "hot-blooded" — Check it and see. Sauron will walk generally in Isildur's direction- keep Elrond away from Sauron, and keep Isildur slightly apart from you front line. However, Atalanta stood standing, a powerful feeling radiating off of her. TOP … He couldn't have known that Isildur would die so soon, and that the ring would go missing. I'm now expecting Amazon's LOTR to be used as a platform to push the sort of agenda we've been seeing in other franchises, with a sensible story taking a . The line of Kings is broken. . It would have tried, as for Elrond and Isildur its a toss up, high elf vs numenorian lord. Isildur (mutters): Bully. He would have become a mighty king - wielding the Ring to bring to his command all the armies of mankind - to one purpose. And with it, the spirit of Elrond. Usually, I see Elrond's supposed ability to push Isildur in justified because 'Elves are infinitely more powerful than men' or something similar. It should have been cast then into Orodruin's fire nigh at hand where it was made. And with it, the spirit of Elrond. To head further, you will have to switch to Elrond (U) and jump onto the upper platform by using the mentioned leaf and afterwards push the rock into the lava to create a path for Isildur. But few marked what Isildur did. Isildur claimed it as weregild after defeating Sauron, and no one bothered enough to risk arguing with the king of Gondor and possibly cause a new war. . . Considering the number of battles that decide the fate of Middle-Earth throughout the ages, there have been many powerful weapons used at several points in Middle-Earth history. ** Many who haven't read the books wonder why, if the ring was so evil, and Isildur wouldn't destroy it, Elrond didn't just grab it from him and destroy it himself, or even just push Isildur into the lava. When counseled by Círdan and Elrond to cast it back into the fires of Mount Doom, he refused, keeping it instead as an heirloom of his house. Isildur kept the Ring. yes,' said Elrond. And eventually Isildur changed his mind when the ring started having effects on him This is purely speculation (and I prefer the theory that the ring could be destroyed by the Valar ) but it is possible that the Valar would not have had the strength to destroy it. Idleness ill suited them and it was noted that tempers began to fray. He would not have wished Isildur's fate on any other man, yet it was possible that he unwittingly had set Boromir on the same dark path. For in destroying the ring through such an act of treachery and betrayal, Elrond would have destroyed himself - and likely broken the Last Alliance into a brutal war between Elves and betrayed Men. ELROND It should have ended that day, but evil was allowed to endure. He chose the simplest explanation to deliver. Elrond was a powerful elf, but he wasn't on the same level as the old High King of the Noldor. For in destroying the ring through such an act of treachery and betrayal, Elrond would have destroyed himsel. There is a reason after all why Sauron sought it over the course of the ages. "Follow me." Elrond led Isildur into the heart of Mount Doom, where the Ring was forged, the one place it could be destroyed. Elrond makes choices. Turning, he gazed at the mural of Isildur, his kin. In the books, no one at that time is sure of exactly what the ring does, Elrond included; they have no idea that it's keeping Sauron alive. And it's true that Elves (and the Half-Elven) are faster, stronger, quicker to heal and more powerful than Men. Come on, if Elrond has just pushed Isildur and the ring down the stupid volcano, there wouldn't have been the need for 11 hours of movie watching! Would have been best if Elrond had not touched the ring, but had instead pushed Isildur into the flames with the ring on his person. Warning: Non-consensual sex. If Elrond wanted to toss him into the fires of Mount Doom, he'd have to carry Isildur up the side of it first, which I don't think is going to happen when their entire armies are standing by watching. . And then it would have filled Isildur with a half-justified rage against Elrond - and all his people. When Isildur took the ring, the only people close enough to see it were Elrond and Cirdan. He founded the two kingdoms of Arnor and Gondors. Pairing: Elrond/Isildur; Elrond/Gil-galad Rating: NC-17 Summary: Companion piece to Possession. ISILDUR No. Elrond gets beat by Sauron and then hides in Imladris until the War of the Last Alliance. Isildur turns and walks away. Follow me! Balrogs are Maiar that were corrupted by Morgoth.We know they can be killed by powerful beings, like the wizards, in single combat because Gandalf killed one. I've seen the post on my dash a couple times about why Elrond didn't just take charge and destroy the ring himself, and though I find it kind of hilarious and I understand that it's a joke, enough people have been taking the stated question seriously to warrant an explanation of why Elrond did not push Isildur into the cracks of Mount Doom, or elf-wrestle it out of his hands and throw it . Answer . Some might argue that giving Isildur a chance to use the One Ring for good was only due to Elrond's own hopes or refusal to take an innocent life, and they'd have a valid point. It would have been the hardest thing to do if he'd taken the life that had fought beside him and ended Sauron, but it's what needed to be done. Elrond frowned as he walked across the library, clutching his fingers carelessly around a paper scroll. Men he can push around thanks to all of Morgoth's groundwork—well, except for those upstart Númenóreans. These weapons range from seemingly plain staffs to powerful magical objects that can spread the . Isildur felt that he was entitled to it. Elrond suggested Isildur destroy it but didn't push the issue when he said no. . Carting Isildur up a mountain to toss him in would be insanely difficult. But few marked what Isildur did. This would be, because the Lord of Imladris is trying to take what is most dear to the. Isildur legitimately claims the Ring as weregild do his father's life. How could Isildur ever trust the elves again? Elrond: Hurry! He explained the rings, the deceit, the web of lies and battles and alliances that had linked together to come to this climax, this moment, where this ring would be destroyed and the Dark Lord Sauron forever crippled. Sauron was also one of the Maiar. For Isildur would not surrender it to Elrond and Círdan who stood by. Rewatching LoTR, endlessly enjoyable as always. Isildur kept the ring in secret, and I think that secrecy is the main reason Elrond didn't push his case. The tale fell with terrible finality into the silence of Lord Elrond's cabinet as the rider, who only named himself Ohtar, confirmed what many had long believed but had refused to admit. Had Elrond and Cirdan kept fighting with him, it's likely that the . The One Ring is undoubtedly a powerful weapon in battle and beyond. What if Elrond push isildur? Little hobbit really rather adorable, blast him. Isildur looks at the Ring. Who says Elrond would have succeeded? yes,' said Elrond. The ring would have been destroyed, as it was at the end of the War of the Ring. Elrond is a fictional man or woman from the films, Der Hobbit: Die Schlacht der fünf Heere. Isildur and Aragorn share a long history and bloodline, leading to the founder of Gondor and Arnor, Elendil the Tall. Isildur stumbled backwards, almost losing his balance as the force of the push forced him to release his grasp on the elf or fall into the lava below. Isildur insisted on keeping the ring for the memory of his father and brother. Cross the stream and destroy the LEGO block to head further to the right. Elrond - Half-elven, herald of Gil-galad, advisor; . But I have so little confidence in the writers and show runners that I despair of such a sensible approach being used. "It is the only way to guarantee the final downfall of the Enemy." I shake my head slowly, they want it, I must protect it. Isildur kept the ring in secret, and I think that secrecy is the main reason Elrond didn't push his case. Chapter One Slave Fields of Northern Nurn Mordor 3441 SA The two Slayers were 'guarded' by four Elven guards as they walked towards a blue and gold shaded pavilion, inside they could see an Elf they didn't recognize and Isildur. His two sons, Isildur and Anárion built the cities of Minas Anor and Minas Ithil, both housing Palantiri and Elendil . the Elf lord continued to push. Cannot believe am getting all swoony over hobbit. Anarion's my favourite out of this list though, dude manages to push Sauron's forces out of Gondor and hold them in Mordor for 5 years until the Last Alliance arrived. Chapter One Walking the Dark Road Author's Note - Glossary of words is at the end of the story. 'Isildur took it, as should not have been. #1. The Hobbits were content to idle a few more days or weeks away, not so the human's in the company. Which was the greater folly, he wondered -- to love in the face of ruin, or to cling to power that was not one's own to wield? Elrond refrains from bonking Isildur on the head with a blunt object and chucking it in while Isildur is out cold. Tons of movies have plot holes and issues that writers just except audiences to look past and not worry about and that's all good and fine, but here I want to see people ask one question that would complete uproot the foundation of a movie they enjoy, assuming the rest of the logic of the world. This is while Sauron has the Ring as well. Return to scene of Gandalf and Elrond. ISILDUR takes the RING. The King of Arnor, hero of the Last Alliance, Isildur firstborn son of Elendil, was slain. Isildur kept the ring in secret, and I think that secrecy is the main reason Elrond didn't push his case. However you are right that Elrond if it dod happen would have no more ability to actually destroy it. Aragorn, son of Arathorn II and Gilraen, was born on March 1st of TA 2931 in Eriador. Or more precisely, he was one of the lesser Ainur who entered the world, and the lesser Ainur were called Maiar. "Isildur, hurry," said, Elrond. 'Alas! Isildur insisted on keeping the ring for the memory of his father and brother. I believe at the time of the ring Galadriel was the most powerful elf to ever walk middle-earth. Elrond: Destroy it! The ring would have been destroyed, as it was at the end of the War of the Ring. If a fight ensued, it is most likely Isildur would win. Elrond and Cirdan have these awesome Rings of their own. "You have always been talking about how you could end this curse by defending your people, by destroying the Ring. Decided to annoy Aragorn by hobbit-napping bite-sized hero and taking him for extended pony ride. This conversation did not happen within the Sammath Naur, as was depicted in the films; it happened on the battlefield after the fighting was over. Perhaps that would have circumvented the ring's power and it's influence at Sammath Naur specifically. Tolkien specifically addressed this — attempting to seize the Ring in an act of force (or push Isildur in) would have corrupted Elrond much quicker than Isildur. Early life. What if Elrond push Isildur? He ended up a dozen steps from Elrond and stood, his gaze falling back to the ring, testing in his hand, assuring himself it was yet there, that he had no lost it. While Elrond remained frozen in his unbearable grief and incredulous anger, Isildur dove to his father's side and wrapped a hand around the hilt of . Elrond could easily beat Isildur (probably even with blindfolded) in a 1v1, but then he is left alone with the ring...and becomes corrupted, resulting in the creation of a badass Elrond, but the destruction of Middle-earth. As Isildur, Elrond, and the Kurosaki trudged up the volcano, Elrond explained what had just happened to the being. "Elrond turned to . Finally decided to take care of Aragorn myself; was about to slit his cheating throat when was distracted by howling moans of Ringbearer. Day Twenty-Six. But Isildur would not listen to our counsel. … He couldn't have known that Isildur would die so soon, and that the ring would go missing. To head further, you will have to switch to Elrond (U) and jump onto the upper platform by using the mentioned leaf and afterwards push the rock into the lava to create a path for Isildur. Elendil and Gil-galad defeat Sauron (dying themselves in the process). It seems like there's just not enough Tolkien to go around, including one of the fandom's favorite topic: Arwen and Aragorn. Isildur wrote, "But for my part I will risk no hurt to this thing: of all the works of Sauron the only fair. For the Ring, wielding Isildur, would have destroyed Elrond. If you were Elrond, standing next to Isildur at the fires of Mount Doom when Isildur refused to destroy the Ring, could you have pushed him into the fire? `Isildur took it, as should not have been. With the Ring gone, there would be no need for any of the Lord Of The Rings movies, and . He was then succeeded by his eldest son, Isildur. Answer (1 of 19): Should Elrond have succeeded in this great betrayal? He was only two years old when Arathorn went riding out against Orcs with the sons of Elrond and was shot in the eye with an orc arrow and died. Just brainstorming on why Elrond and Cirdan didn't push any harder at Isildur to destroy the Ring. Aragorn did not know. It should have been cast then into Orodruin's fire nigh at hand where it was made. They counselled him to cast it into the fire of Orodruin nigh at hand, in which it had been forged, so that it should perish, and the power of Sauron be for ever diminished, and he should remain only as a shadow of malice in the wilderness. Isildur gazed at the ring as it shrunk to his size, as the markings of the band began to fade. What if Elrond push isildur? Making Isildur the main character would make sense because he is actually mentioned to do specific things. ELROND I led Isildur into the heart of Mount Doom, where it was forged, the one place it could be destroyed. Another misadventure in the house of Elrond The company of nine had been set and now they waited for the last of the messengers to return before setting off. Isildur took it! Similarly, the armies of Men had fractured after Elendil and Isildur's deaths. Galadriel was Most Powerful Elf to Walk Middle-earth At the time of the war of the ring, there remained multiple great elf lord's in Middle-earth.In Rivendell, for example, dwelt the very wise and keeper of the ring of Sapphire, Master Elrond Lord of Rivendell . He alone stood by his father in that last mortal contest; and by Gil-galad only Círdan stood, and I. As Sauron's attack cause massive area of effect damage, nesting Isildur in your front line will cause your forces to buckle quicker. Elendil was born in Númenor and was a part of the faithful. Isildur was the second High King of Arnor and Gondor. Similarly, the other races of Elves had begun leaving Middle Earth, seeing that their time was ending and humanity was taking over. ELROND Follow me! As Isildur, Elrond, and the Kurosaki trudged up the volcano, Elrond explained what had just happened to the being. In the book he does not take Isildur into the mountain. What if Elrond push isildur? An adaptation of J. R. R. Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings into a film trilogy directed by Peter Jackson.The movies were filmed together and released one year after the previous for the holiday seasons 2001-2003.. One of the most ambitious movie projects ever undertaken, the overall budget was around $300 million (estimates vary between $281-330 million) and principal filming for all three . Isildur insisted on keeping the ring for the memory of his father and brother. I. It was the one where he allowed Isildur to flee. If he did kill Isildur, that would precipitate a war between the descendants of Numenor and the Elves. As they walked in Buffy blanched even as she felt Faith jerk to a . Elrond walks up to Isildur. An elf named Glorfindel killed a Balrog in the First Age. A better addition than Isildur but still Human would be Anarion, Elendil, Hurin, Huor, Turin or Tuor. Elrond of the Elves came to Isildur amongst the smoted ruins of Sauron and bade him follow to Mount Doom, where the One Ring had been forged. Galadriel vs balrog is a great match. Cross the stream and destroy the LEGO block to head further to the right. Apr 19 Isildur, Gildor, and Elrond leave Barad-dûr Apr 24 Gildor and Elrond part from Isildur at Morannon Apr 25 Gildor and Elrond camp at Emyn Muil Apr 27 Gildor and Elrond cross Anduin at Celebrant Apr 28 Isildur arrives at Rauros and crosses Anduin; Gildor and Elrond arrive in Lothlórien And with it, the spirit of Elrond. But at the flashback to Elrond and Isildur I couldn't help but notice that Elrond pleads to Isildur to cast the ring into the fire, and Isildur is basically like "yeah, no" and Elrond is "ehhhh I am not pleased with this reply but I'm going to let you leave with this ultra powerful artifact that will eventually potentially destroy the world". Both Isildur and Aragorn were mighty warriors, true Kings, and leaders of Men, but only one had the respect of the Elves - and there's a reason. He explained the rings, the deceit, the web of lies and battles and alliances that had linked together to come to this climax, this moment, where this ring would be destroyed and the Dark Lord Sauron forever crippled. He foresaw the fall of the kingdom and left with the faithful to Middle-earth. Aragorn, then the Heir of Isildur, was taken to live in Rivendell with Elrond. Jan 22, 2020. He also didn't fully . The One Ring and it's survival by the hands of Isildur gave rise to Sauron and the War of the Ring in the Lord of the Rings, but what if Elrond had pushed Is. The power it contains would have made this ancient . Probably not wearing them as Corey jokingly suggested in class, as they just moments ago finished battle with Sauron with his Ruling Ring on his hand. Elrond: Cast it into the fire! Isildur had saved a . Destroy it! Is this film based on a ebook? In the present, Kate was bowing to Lord Elrond, and Ashley followed suit.
Richard Pryor Horns Shirt, Social Determinants Of Mental Health Pdf, Basf Wyandotte Apprenticeship Program, When Did Denmark And Norway Separate, Jetbrains Developer Ecosystem Survey 2021, Naperville Park District Summer Camps, Hyaluronic Acid On Burns, Architectural Associate Job Description,
